MyCase vs CasePeer: 2026 Comparison for PI Law Firms
An honest comparison of MyCase and CasePeer for law firms. See features, strengths, and which is right for your practice.
Here's something most people don't realize: MyCase and CasePeer are both owned by 8AM (formerly AffiniPay). They're sister products under the same parent company. But they serve different markets — MyCase is a general-purpose tool, CasePeer was built for personal injury.
Feature Comparison
| Feature | MyCase | CasePeer | Importance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Built for PI out of the box | ✗ | ✓ | high |
| Ease of use | Very easy | Very easy | high |
| Multi-practice support | Any practice area | PI-focused only | medium |
| Settlement calculators | ✗ | ✓ | medium |
| Mobile app | ✓ | ✗ | medium |
| Client portal | Built-in portal | ✗ | medium |
| Third-party integrations | Good (QuickBooks, etc.) | Recently added API | medium |
| Needs a dedicated admin | ✗ | ✗ | high |
| Client portal | MyCase portal (messaging, docs, payments) | ✗ | medium |
| Built-in e-signatures | Unlimited, included free | Via Dropbox Sign | medium |
| Parent company | 8AM (formerly AffiniPay) | 8AM (formerly AffiniPay) | low |
Client Portal Comparison
Case management systems organize your office. Quilia engages your clients. Here's what each platform's portal actually offers.
| Capability | MyCase | CasePeer | Quilia |
|---|---|---|---|
| Log medical appointments and treatments | ✗ | No portal | ✓ |
| Daily pain score tracking | ✗ | — | ✓ |
| Automated treatment reminders | ✗ | — | ✓ |
| Secure messaging with legal team | ✓ | — | ✓ |
| Upload documents from phone | ✓ | — | ✓ |
| View case status updates | ✓ | — | ✓ |
| Online invoice payments | ✓ | — | ✓ |
| Push notification alerts | ✗ | — | ✓ |
| Multilingual support (10+ languages) | ✗ | — | ✓ |
| Watch educational case videos | ✗ | — | ✓ |
MyCase vs CasePeer Strengths
MyCase Strengths
- ✓Supports any practice area
- ✓Built-in client portal
- ✓Mobile app available
- ✓Good third-party integrations (QuickBooks, etc.)
- ✓Intuitive, straightforward interface
CasePeer Strengths
- ✓Built specifically for personal injury
- ✓Settlement calculators included
- ✓PI-specific workflows out of the box
- ✓Highly reliable with low downtime
- ✓No setup needed for PI use cases
Our Take
Pick MyCase if:
Choose MyCase if your firm handles multiple practice areas and wants a versatile, easy-to-use system with a built-in client portal and mobile app.
Pick CasePeer if:
Choose CasePeer if you're strictly a personal injury firm and want a system that was purpose-built for PI — settlement calculators, PI workflows, no configuration needed.
Either way:
MyCase has a basic client portal and CasePeer has none. Quilia integrates with both to add real client engagement — automated reminders, treatment tracking, and proactive communication that keeps clients active.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are MyCase and CasePeer owned by the same company?
Yes — both MyCase and CasePeer are owned by 8AM (formerly AffiniPay). They're sister products under the same parent company but serve different markets. MyCase is a general-purpose tool for any practice area. CasePeer was built specifically for personal injury. Despite shared ownership, they're distinct products with different feature sets.
Is MyCase or CasePeer better for personal injury firms?
CasePeer was built specifically for PI — it has settlement calculators, PI-specific workflows, and an interface designed around how injury firms work. MyCase is a solid general-purpose tool but wasn't designed with PI in mind. If you're strictly a PI firm, CasePeer is the more natural fit.
What if my firm handles more than just personal injury?
MyCase is the better choice for multi-practice firms. CasePeer is focused on personal injury and doesn't offer much flexibility outside of PI. If you handle family law, criminal defense, or other areas alongside PI, MyCase gives you one system for everything.
How do MyCase and CasePeer compare on ease of use?
Both are very easy to use — they're designed for firms that want a straightforward system without complexity. Neither requires a dedicated administrator or consultant. The learning curve is minimal for both platforms.
Does Quilia work with both MyCase and CasePeer?
Yes. Quilia integrates with both platforms. Whether you choose MyCase's general-purpose approach or CasePeer's PI-specific system, Quilia handles client engagement — automated reminders, treatment tracking, and communication.
Quilia Works with Both MyCase and CasePeer
Whichever CMS you choose, Quilia adds the client engagement layer — automated reminders, treatment tracking, and communication your clients actually use.